History, Book or Movie?

STORYSMART® • November 5, 2023

What is the best way to share your history?

Introduction

The rich tapestry of history is woven with countless stories, some etched in books, while others come to life on the big screen. The decision of whether to share your history through a book or a documentary film is a critical one, and it is not to be taken lightly.

Organizations like labor unions and family-owned businesses, as well as individuals such as former congressmen or titans of industry, often grapple with this choice. The decision goes beyond mere storytelling; it's about legacy preservation, connecting with the audience, and leaving a lasting impact.

In this blog post, we'll explore the pros and cons of both mediums and emphasize the importance of structuring your preservation storytelling with the end in mind. Moreover, we'll strongly recommend considering the services of a professional storytelling filmmaking company for a seamless and impactful journey.


Part 1: The Power of Storytelling

Before diving into the book vs. movie debate, it's crucial to understand the power of storytelling in preserving history. Whether it's an organization's journey, a family's legacy, or an individual's experiences, storytelling is the thread that connects the past to the present and the future. Stories have a unique ability to engage, educate, and inspire audiences, making them a valuable tool for preserving history.


1.1 The Essence of Books

Books are timeless vessels of storytelling. They offer an in-depth, immersive experience that allows readers to step into the shoes of the storyteller. For organizations and individuals looking to preserve their history, a well-crafted book can be a repository of knowledge, emotions, and insights. Books provide a space for in-depth exploration, detailed explanations, and a thorough examination of events and experiences.


1.2 The Power of Movies

Documentary films, on the other hand, are a dynamic way to share history. They combine visuals, sound, and motion to create an emotional connection with the audience. The power of film lies in its ability to bring history to life, making it a compelling medium for organizations, families, and individuals who want to engage viewers and leave a lasting impact.


Part 2: The Pros and Cons

Now that we've established the significance of storytelling, let's weigh the pros and cons of both books and documentary films when sharing your history.


2.1 Books


Pros:

- Detailed and in-depth exploration of events and experiences.

- Allows for nuanced storytelling and character development.

- Readers can engage with the material at their own pace.

- Cost-effective to produce, especially with self-publishing options.

- Simple way to monetize by selling digital downloads or print on demand books


Cons:

- Limited reach compared to films.

- May not engage younger, visually-oriented audiences.

- Requires strong writing skills or the assistance of a professional writer.

- Readership may be limited to those interested in reading.


2.2 Documentary Films


Pros:

- Visually engaging and emotionally impactful.

- Appeals to a wider audience, including younger generations.

- Incorporates interviews, real footage, and music for a more immersive experience.

- Potential for broader distribution through film festivals, streaming platforms, and television.


Cons:

- Requires more significant upfront investment.

- Dependent on the availability of skilled filmmakers.

- Limited to a specific runtime, potentially restricting the depth of storytelling.

- Can be a complex production process.


Part 3: Structuring Preservation Storytelling with the End in Mind

Before diving into the book or film production, it's crucial to start with the end in mind. What are your goals for preserving your history, and who is your target audience? Answering these questions will help you make an informed decision. This is the fundamental starting point in our conversation with new clients at STORYSMART®. “Begin with the end in mind” is sort of a mantra for us. Doing that on the front end brings maximum benefit.


3.1 Define Your Goals

Whether you are a labor union, a family-owned business, or an individual, your reasons for sharing your history can vary. It could be to educate, inspire, raise awareness, or even pass down knowledge to future generations. Clearly define your objectives, as they will guide the storytelling process.


3.2 Know Your Audience

Understanding your audience is paramount. Different mediums cater to different demographics. If your goal is to connect with a broader, visually-oriented audience, a documentary film may be the way to go. However, if you seek to provide a comprehensive account for scholars or a more immersive experience for readers, a book could be the better choice.


3.3 Planning for Preservation

Once your goals and audience are defined, the preservation storytelling process can begin. For books, this means structuring your narrative, researching extensively, and crafting a compelling story. For documentary films, it involves planning the visuals, conducting interviews, and creating a captivating script. Regardless of the medium, meticulous planning is key to a successful preservation project. With our client work with STORYSMART®, we are big advocates for building a digital archive that helps with your storytelling regardless of whether you plan to do filmmaking, video marketing or publishing. The value of organizing your collection comes into play from a fact verification standpoint, as well as sharing beautiful visuals in your filmmaking and publishing.


Part 4: The Case for Professional Storytelling Filmmaker

If you're leaning toward creating a documentary film to preserve your history, it's highly recommended to seek the services of a professional storytelling filmmaking company. Here are some compelling reasons why:


4.1 Expertise and Experience

Professional filmmaking companies bring a wealth of experience to the table. They have the skills to handle the intricacies of video production, including scripting, shooting, editing, and post-production. Their expertise ensures a high-quality and engaging final product.


4.2 Resources

Filmmaking requires access to equipment, technology, and personnel. A professional company has all the necessary resources at its disposal, sparing you the time and expense of acquiring them yourself.


4.3 Creative Vision

Filmmaking companies have a knack for storytelling that extends beyond the camera. They can help you develop a creative and impactful narrative that resonates with your audience. Their creative vision can transform a mundane story into a gripping, emotionally resonant film.


4.4 Efficient Project Management

Producing a documentary film can be a complex and time-consuming process. Professional filmmakers excel in project management, ensuring that your story is delivered on time and within budget. They can handle logistics, scheduling, and coordination seamlessly.


4.5 Distribution Channels

A professional filmmaking company can guide you on distribution strategies, ensuring that your documentary reaches a wide and relevant audience. This includes submission to film festivals, online streaming platforms, and television networks, helping your story gain the exposure it deserves.


Part 5: Final Thoughts

In the age of digital media, there are numerous avenues to preserve and share your history. Whether you choose a book or a documentary film (or both in tandem), the key is to structure your storytelling with the end in mind. Define your goals, know your audience, and plan for preservation. Each medium has its pros and cons, and your decision should align with your objectives.

While books offer depth and nuance, documentary films provide a visually engaging and emotionally impactful experience. When it comes to filmmaking, enlisting the services of a professional storytelling filmmaking company can make all the difference. Their expertise, resources, creative vision, and efficient project management can elevate your story to new heights.

In the end, the choice between a book and a documentary film is a personal one, guided by your history, your goals, and your audience. Please also know that you can do both and planning to do both in tandem provides the maximum benefit.

Regardless of your decision, remember that the power of storytelling is in your hands, and it has the potential to shape the way your history is remembered for generations to come. At STORYSMART®, we specialize in helping organizations with documentary filmmaking to preserve their stories as a timeless legacy, as well as using cinematic storytelling to help market their brand online. If you are interested in learning more, please schedule a FREE storytelling filmmaking consultation now.


About STORYSMART®

You have a story to bring to the screen, but you don't have the time, talent, or resources to do it yourself. Telling your story well with a film can be hard. Few can produce a do-it-yourself (DIY) video we want to watch, much less a beautiful film we will always remember.

To do justice to your story on screen, you need a professional filmmaker with the right skills, equipment, time, money, storytelling, and filmmaking talent.

That is why STORYSMART® developed our premium filmmaking storytelling service. We help discerning clients tell their story in the amazing cinematic way they deserve with a proprietary done-for-you filmmaking storytelling service unlike any other.

The Real Story Behind The Wire

By Ron Watermon • June 2, 2026
The Wire Wasn't Just Invented. It Was Reported.

Making Steak on a Hamburger Budget

By Ron Watermon • May 30, 2026
Filmmaking for ALL™ Lesson One

Who Gets to Profit From a True Story?

By Ron Watermon • May 24, 2026
Exploring the Ethical Tensions of Investment and Profit Sharing in Documentary Filmmaking

The Real Story Behind Michael

By Ron Watermon • May 19, 2026
What the Michael Jackson Biopic Teaches Us About Storytelling

From Amityville to The Exorcist

By Ron Watermon • May 5, 2026
Why "True Story" Horror is So Profitable

The Cobbler's Son Finally Gets Shoes

By Ron Watermon • May 1, 2026
Why I'm Changing How I (and STORYSMART®) Tell Stories

MEDIA LENS: From Rescue Mission to Movie Deal

By Ron Watermon • April 26, 2026
How a Story of a U.S. Airman Shot Down in Iran is Already Becoming a Feature Film

From Shoebox to Screenplay

By Ron Watermon • April 21, 2026
Turning Photos into Cinematic Storytelling Assets

From Brand Storytelling to Owned Media

By Ron Watermon • April 7, 2026
There are moments in your career that don’t feel particularly significant at the time, but years later, you realize they changed everything. The television show we started when I was with the St. Louis Cardinals, Cardinals Insider, is now heading into its 11th season. In an industry where most things don’t last, there’s something meaningful about building something that endures. While I've already shared the story of how the show almost didn’t happen, what’s been on my mind recently is what we were doing before it ever aired. For me the show was never the starting point, it was a destination on a journey that began seventeen years ago when I decided to fully commit to becoming a brand journalist. A Baseball Brand Journalist When I moved over to the Baseball Operations Department to work with our Media Relations team in September 2009, the media landscape looked very different than it does today. Social media was still in its infancy. We had exactly one platform we controlled, Twitter, and even that was a bit of a mess. Our account was @MLBstlcardinals, while Major League Baseball operated @stlcardinals out of New York. It was confusing for fans and limiting for us. But it also created an opportunity. Instead of waiting for others to tell our story, we decided to start telling it ourselves. Not as marketers, but as actual storytellers. More specifically, we adopted a mindset rooted in journalism. The fundamentals I learned years earlier in college—who, what, when, where, why, and how. The discipline of getting it right. The importance of clarity, structure, and credibility. We weren’t trying to spin the story. We were trying to tell it honestly, accurately, and from a clearly defined point of view. That point of view mattered. We made a promise to our audience: we would cover the team like journalists, but from the inside. We weren’t going to pretend to be something we weren’t. We were insiders. That was the advantage. And instead of hiding from it, we leaned into it. At the same time, we understood the responsibility that came with that position. We didn’t need to be first. We needed to be right. That meant establishing standards. It meant covering the good moments like the wins, the milestones, and the behind-the-scenes access fans couldn’t get anywhere else. But it also meant not ignoring the harder stories when they arose. Credibility was always at stake, and we treated it that way. I knew were building something. A system. A mindset. A way of approaching storytelling that went beyond promotion and into something far more durable. Over time, that approach evolved into a weekly TV show that’s still on the air more than a decade later. But none of that happens without what came first. The decision to think as brand journalists with a point of view. Brand Journalists with a Point of View What we were building in those early days didn’t look like much from the outside. There was no studio. No formal production schedule. No distribution strategy beyond posting to social media and linking out to photos and video. In fact, some of the earliest tools we used would feel almost laughable today.

The Show That Almost Wasn't Begins 11th Season on TV

By Ron Watermon • April 2, 2026
St. Louis, April 1, 2026 - Last week I had one of those “ no shit, Sherlock ” moments where the obvious hits you all at once. I was thinking about Opening Day. Like I’ve done the past few years, I planned to share a throwback post from ten years ago. I dig into my photo archive, find a few cell phone images from seasons past, and put something out on social media. Posting doesn’t come naturally to me. I know that sounds ironic given what I do now, but I’ve never been particularly drawn to self-promotion or the performative nature of those platforms. After all, I’m a middle-aged introvert, not some Gen Z dude who grew up with social media and enjoys showing off. I hate shameless self-promotion and bragging. That said, I have a fellow Gen X friend who has been chirping at me for years to share more about my time with the St. Louis Cardinals. I headed her advice and started digging. What I found stopped me. As I worked my way through old photos, I realized that 2016 wasn’t just another season. It was the year we honored Lou Brock and the year we launched Cardinals Insider, the television show I developed and produced during my time with the club. That’s when it hit me. It has been a decade. And the show is not only still around— it’s thriving . I must tip my cap to my colleagues at the Cardinals as they have continued to invest in it, expand it, and build on the foundation we put in place back in 2016. It is truly remarkable. Seeing that now as I’ve transitioned my business into filmmaking, hit me in a profound way. It was literally an “aha” moment. Like a lot of entrepreneurs and creatives, I’ve wrestled with self-doubt. You question whether you’re on the right path. Whether the work you’re doing is building toward something. Realizing that this show that I fought to make happen has now run for more than a decade was affirming. Because the vision was never small. From the beginning, the goal was to build something self-sustaining that would continue to grow and evolve long after I was gone. And it has, big time. That realization couldn’t have happened form me at a better time.
Show More